Managing Rising Medical Costs While Supporting Employee Health

Managing Rising Medical Costs While Supporting Employee Health

Medical insurance remains an essential employee benefit, but rising premiums are putting significant pressure on employer budgets and employees alike. For small and mid-sized government contractors, the challenge is managing costs while maintaining competitive benefits that support recruitment, retention and employee well-being.


The good news and the bad news

The bad news: Medical costs are expected to continue rising. Marsh's September 2026 preliminary survey projects an average 8.2% increase in employer health benefit costs in 2027, rising to 11% without cost-reduction measures.

The good news: Employers have options beyond simply increasing employee premium contributions or deductibles. Understanding what drives costs and evaluating alternative plan designs, provider networks, prescription drug strategies and preventive health resources can help employers make more informed decisions.


What is driving medical costs higher?

Several factors are contributing to rising premiums:

· Prescription drugs: Pharmacy accounted for 29.5% of total claims spending in Benefitfocus's 2025 data, up from 27.2% in 2024. Brand-name drugs without generic alternatives and specialty medications represented 87.6% of prescription spending while accounting for only 14% of prescriptions filled. This illustrates how a relatively small number of prescriptions can account for a disproportionate share of costs.

· Specialty and weight-loss medications: UnitedHealthcare reports that specialty medications represent approximately 55% of pharmacy benefit spending. Marsh estimates that increased use of GLP-1 medications for weight management adds one percentage point to projected 2027 health benefit cost growth.

· Chronic conditions and high-cost claims: Cancer, cardiovascular disease, diabetes and other ongoing conditions can generate substantial recurring expenses. UnitedHealthcare reports that claims of $100,000 or more increased 12.9% from 2024 to 2025.

· Hospital and provider costs: Higher treatment costs, increasingly expensive medical technology, provider consolidation and greater bargaining power among health systems also contribute to rising prices.


These statistics reflect different industry surveys and claims populations; individual employer plans may experience different cost drivers.


What are the most common employer-sponsored medical plans?

KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey reports the following distribution of covered workers by plan type.


Plan type Share of covered workers (2026) How it works Key consideration for employers

PPO — Preferred Provider

Organization 50% Offers in-network and out-of-network coverage, usually without referrals to specialists. Greater provider flexibility, but premiums can be higher.

HDHP with savings option

— High-Deductible Health

Plan with HSA or HRA 29% Higher deductible paired with a Health Savings Account (HSA) or Health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA). May lower premiums; consider employer account contributions and employee out-of-pocket exposure.

HMO — Health Maintenance Organization 12% Generally uses a defined network and does not cover non-emergency out-of-network care. Can offer cost-effective coverage, but employees have less provider flexibility.

POS — Point of Service 8% Combines network-based care with out-of-network options; referrals may be required for some services. Offers a middle ground between cost controls and flexibility.

Conventional / indemnity Less than 1% Generally does not use preferred provider networks and reimburses covered services under plan terms. Less common in today's employer market.


For small and mid-sized government contractors facing double-digit renewals, the best starting point is to ask the broker to compare the current plan against viable alternatives, including:

· A different PPO or carrier with competitive pricing and adequate provider access.

· An HSA-qualified HDHP, evaluating whether premium savings justify the higher deductible and whether an employer HSA contribution would help employees.

· HMO or EPO options where the local provider network adequately serves the workforce.

· Different employer/employee premium-sharing arrangements, while meeting applicable ACA affordability requirements.


Practical ways to manage costs

Employers should work with their benefits broker to evaluate opportunities that fit their workforce, budget and benefit philosophy.


1. Review claims and identify cost drivers. Ask the broker to explain the factors behind the renewal increase, including high-cost claims, recurring conditions, prescription drug spending and utilization trends. Review available claims reports and benchmarks to identify opportunities for targeted intervention.

2. Compare plans and provider networks. Evaluate alternative carriers, plan designs, network options and funding arrangements where appropriate. High-deductible health plans paired with Health Savings Accounts (HSAs), different copay structures and tiered provider networks may offer savings, but compare total costs, provider access and employee out-of-pocket exposure—not just premiums.

3. Examine prescription drug spending. Ask the broker to review pharmacy benefit options, generic and biosimilar alternatives where clinically appropriate, formularies, specialty drug management and available savings programs. Review GLP-1 coverage criteria and costs while considering clinical needs and potential long-term benefits.

4. Improve access to appropriate care. Encourage preventive screenings, routine primary care, chronic condition management and care navigation. Virtual care and employee assistance programs may also improve access to convenient medical and behavioral health support. Evaluate these options based on employee needs and measurable results.


Helping employees become healthier

Employers can support employee well-being while helping people make informed healthcare decisions:


· Encourage preventive care: Promote covered preventive screenings, recommended vaccinations and routine checkups.

· Support chronic condition management: Communicate available resources for diabetes, hypertension, heart disease and other ongoing conditions.

· Make healthy choices easier: Consider voluntary wellness initiatives supporting physical activity, nutrition, stress management and tobacco cessation.

· Promote mental health: Remind employees about employee assistance programs, behavioral health benefits and virtual counseling.

· Improve healthcare literacy: Help employees understand their plans, use in-network providers, compare costs and make informed care decisions.


Wellness programs should be accessible and appropriate for the employee population. Better health outcomes take time, and employers should not assume that wellness initiatives will immediately reduce premiums.


Make your broker a strategic partner

Your benefits broker should be an active partner in managing medical costs—not simply obtaining renewal rates. Work together to review claims trends, compare viable alternatives, explain the financial and employee impact of proposed changes, and develop a sustainable benefits strategy.


Your broker can help explain what is driving your medical renewal increase using available claims reports, utilization trends and prescription drug data. Ask for an overall review of medical and pharmacy spending, high-cost claims, chronic conditions and other major cost drivers, along with recommendations tailored to your workforce.


The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) generally permits the sharing of summary health information for purposes such as obtaining insurance bids and evaluating plan changes. However, access to detailed claims information varies by plan, insurer and broker authorization. Employers should request aggregated or appropriately de-identified reports and avoid unnecessary employee-specific medical details. Smaller groups may require additional care to prevent individuals from being identified. The objective is to understand the overall cost picture and identify practical solutions—not to access individual employees' medical information.


Recommended next step

C2 Essentials, as your HR and Benefits partner, can schedule a renewal strategy discussion with your broker. At the meeting the broker will explain the proposed increase, compare plan alternatives, review prescription and high-cost claims, and recommend cost management while maintaining meaningful coverage. The goal is not simply to find the lowest premium. It is to balance affordability, employee health and the long-term sustainability of your medical plan.


Additional resources

Marsh — 2027 Employer Health Benefit Cost Projections

KFF — 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey

Benefitfocus — 2026 State of Employee Benefits Report

UnitedHealthcare — 2026 Health Trends Report

Business Group on Health — 2026 Trends to Watch

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services — HIPAA Privacy Rule